A.J's Grilled Cheese

(on west montauk highway)
Caterers in Bay Shore, NY
Caterers
Food
Restaurants

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
11:00AM - 9:00PM
Wednesday
11:00AM - 9:00PM
Thursday
11:00AM - 9:00PM
Friday
11:00AM - 9:00PM
Saturday
11:00AM - 9:00PM
Sunday
11:00AM - 8:00PM

Location

182 West Montauk Highway
Bay Shore, NY
11706

About

A casual vibe serving Hearty Soups, Salads and Gourmet Grilled Cheeses

Photos

A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo A.J's Grilled Cheese Photo

Latest A.J's Grilled Cheese Reviews (Average Rating: 3.5)

based on 188 review(s)

One of my mother's favorite childhood stories about me is how I used to sneak into the kitchen late at night and eat cheese. The passion for the delectable...

Fredrika C. June 26, 2020 via Yelp

I've been meaning to check this place out ever since they opened, and gave it a shot about five months ago. Tale of the tape: The Philly Melt Grilled...

Chris C. October 11, 2020 via Yelp

This place has been on my list for quite a while and I was in the area so I decided to give it a try. I called in my order over the phone and was told it...

Briana R. August 27, 2020 via Yelp

Latest

Our Buffalo Chicken grilled cheese with bacon! 👌🏼🧀🥓 #pepperjackcheese #buffalochicken #bacon #grilledcheese #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lirestaurants #eatingli #lieats #foodphotography #food #foodstagram #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover
Happy Saturday! Come check us out tonight until 9 pm! #milkshake #cottoncandy #churro #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lirestaurants #lifood #eatingli #lieats #food #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodie #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore
Our pretzel bites 👌🏼🥨🧀 #pretzels #pretzelbites #cheese #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lieats #eat #eatlocal #eatingli #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodie #longislandfoodies #foodforfoodies #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore
There’s nothing better then a classic grilled cheese 🤪 #traditonal #grilledcheese #cheese #lieats #longislandeats #longislandfoodie #food #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodiesofinstagram #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #eatlocal
New beer selection all stocked up in our fridge today! 🍻 #blueberryale #oktoberfest #pumpkinale #bluepoint #greatsouthbay #beer #pumpkin #pumpkinseason #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lieats #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore
Pumpkin beer is back! 🎃🍺 #bluepoint #pumpkin #pumpkinbeer #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #instagood #longislandfoodie #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lieats
We love seeing our customers enjoying our milkshakes! 💕 #cottoncandy #milkshake #cottoncandymilkshake #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #instadaily #instagood #instafood #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodie #foodiesofinstagram #lifoodies #lirestaurants #lieats #eatingli
Come stop in for our beer paring with @bluepointbrewing today🍻🍺🧀 Our pairing menu ⬇️ • Blue Point the IPA paired with The French Onion Soup grilled cheese • Blue Point Oktoberfest paired with The Smoke Out • Blue Point Blueberry Ale paired with The Jalapeño Popper grilled cheese • Blue Point Pumpkin Ale paired with The Apple and Bacon
Who else can’t wait for our beer pairing with Blue Point tomorrow?! We will be serving beer flights with 4 signature grilled cheese samplers all day long, along with our regular menu! Blue Point will be on site 4-8 pm with free samples and giveaways! 🍺🍻🧀 #bluepoint #bluepointbrewery #beer #beerstagram #beerlover #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #cheese #food #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodie #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover #foodforfoodies #lifoodies #lifoodgram #eatingli #longislandfoodie #bayshore
It’s officially soup season 🥳 Our soup selection today ⬇️ • Tomato Bisque • Butternut Squash and Apple • New England Clam Chowder
The Smoke Out is back for the month of October! 🙌🏼 Pulled BBQ pork, fried pickles, coleslaw and smoked gouda cheese all between sourdough bread! #octoberspecial #smokeout #lifoodies #lifoodgram #lieats #longislandfoodie #munchies #feastagram #eatingforinsta #foodphotography #foodstagram #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #eatingli #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover
New AJ’S apparel is now for sale! Come check it out 🧀 thanks to @lovelyletteringcorner for our custom sticker! #lifeisgouda #reinventinganamericancomfortfood #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #lieats #eatingli #foodiesofinstagram
You aren’t going to want to miss out on our French Onion soup 🤪🧀 #frenchonionsoup #frenchonion #cheese #soup #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #lifoodies #lirestaurants #lifood #lieats #eatinglongisland #eatinglocal #food #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover #foodpics #bayshore
ATTENTION ❗️ We have been notified by the tracing process that a positive Covid-19 case was present within the past 24 hours inside our restaurant. As an abundance of precaution and for the safety & health of our staff and customers we will be closed as of now and through tomorrow for professional sanitation of the establishment. We do regularly sanitize with disinfectant products but would like to take the extra step of closing for 24 hours as precautionary measures.
This is your sign to get a Mac N Cheese Melt today 🙌🏼🧀 #macandcheesemelt #macandcheese #grilledcheese #cheese #lifoodies #lirestaurants #lifood #lieats #eatingli #eating #food #foodphotography #foodstagram #foodie #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover #foodpics
The Gobbler is back for the month of November! 🍂 Turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing and Munster cheese all between sourdough bread! #grilledcheese #november #specialofthemonth #instagood #instagram #instafood #food #foodie #foodstagram #foodphotography #foodiesofinstagram #lifoodies #lieats #eatingli #bayshore #11706
The Gobbler 🙌🏼 #turkey #stuffing #cranberrysauce #muenstercheese #lifoodies #lifood #lirestaurants #lifoodie #eating #eatingli #food #foodie #foodstagram #foodphotography #foodiesofinstagram #foodlover #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore
Happy Thanksgiving! 🦃🍽 We will be closed today but be sure to get your AJs fix on tomorrow in between Black Friday shopping 🛍. It has been a wild year , take this day to enjoy your family and have positive thoughts to move forward into a GREAT 2021 🍁
Our most popular special is back on the menu for the month of December! “The Roast Beast” which features beef loin slow cooked in red wine, crispy onion strings, Muenster cheese, and a light horseradish spread 😋🎄#ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #lifoodie #lieats
Happy Holidays from our family to yours! 2020 was definitely an unprecedented one for all. We wish nothing but health, happiness, and prosperity to all of our great customers. Thank you for your continued support throughout the year. #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #holidays#happyhanukkah #merrychristmas #celebrate #lieats #lifoodies
Happy New Year! 🎊 Cheers to 2021. We will be open for dinner at 4 PM today. #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #2021 #NewYear #grilledcheese #lieats
We bring you this news 📰 with a heavy heart. We hope this is not the end, but rather the beginning of a new and better chapter. Covid-19 has impacted all of us, some in different ways than others. The restaurant industry is changing dramatically, at least for the time-being. Just like many other situations in life we need to adapt and transform. We will be closed today and this entire week while we re-imagine our business. We will be introducing our new plan over the course of this week so that all of you will have an opportunity to continue your patronage at our restaurant while enjoying some of the nation’s best grilled cheese sandwiches! This new plan may include a limited menu and limited weekend hours....We will not give up during these very challenging times. We appreciate all of your business and look forward to servicing you all sooner than later! #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #lieats #eatingli #covid19 #bayshore #11706
We will be back this Friday night 5-9PM and Saturday 2-9PM. We will be featuring this temporary revised menu ! Stop down and get your AJs fix 🤩
Just by coincidence @ajsgrilledcheeseshop opened its doors 5 years ago on this day! After a long difficult year we were faced with challenges and will now today re-open and try to triumph those challenges. We started this business with family behind the reigns and today we re-open with family behind the reigns. Only time will tell what is in store for us but we are proud to say we are giving it our all and hope that everyone joins us! Thank you for your patience and support as always 🎉 Now lets get our CHEESE on. Our temporary menu will be available Fridays 5-9pm and Saturdays 2-9PM. #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #smallbusiness #grilledcheese #bestaround #lieats #longislandfoodie @barstoolfund 🙏😬
Check us out!!! We are open tonight 5-9PM and tomorrow 1-9PM ‼️🎉🍻#beer #grilledcheese #bayshore #smallbusiness #lieats #lifoodie
We will be open Friday 5-9PM and Saturday 1-9PM‼️ If you would like some loaded chips or maybe a build your own grilled cheese kit for the bug game Sunday. oOder from us on Instagram by dropping a message in our DM or email us at info@ajsgrilledcheese.com 😍 All orders must be picked up the night before.
A.J's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop updated their phone number.
A.J's Gourmet Grilled Cheese Shop updated their phone number.
Who said a grilled cheese couldn’t be healthy?! 😅 Stop in until 9PM tonight and create an over the top grilled cheese concoction 📸#ajsgrilledcheeseshop #bayshore #11706 #grilledcheese #lieats #eatinglongisland #lifoodies
BIG NEWS 🗞 Our mac bites are making its return this weekend! We are open today 1PM - 9PM ‼️ #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #lieats #lifoodies #11706
HELLO Mac Bites😍 ...Stop in tonight until 9PM or tomorrow from 1-9PM ‼️Say cheese 📸🧀 #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #grilledcheese #macbites #delicious #homemade #shoplocal #bayshore #11706 #lieats #lifoodies #eatingli #lifoodie
The weather is beautiful as we get a taste of spring today! Check out this new menu item! For those looking for a healthy meal we have you covered ‼️🔷🔷we are open Fridays 5-9PM and Saturdays 1-9PM🔷🔷Our new “Healthy grilled chicken wrap” features grilled chicken, sautéed onions, peppers, and diced tomato tossed in lite honey mustard sauce. Substitute the side for some grilled broccoli (free side) or sweet potato tots for an extra filling! Just $9.00 plus tax with broccoli as a side 🥦 🫑 #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #healthyoptions #mealprepcomingsoon #wraps #lieats #lifoodies #fitlife #fitness #protein
Check out this new menu item! For those looking for a healthy meal we have you covered ‼️🔷🔷we are open Fridays 5-9PM and Saturdays 1-9PM🔷🔷Our new “Healthy wrap” features grilled chicken, sautéed onions, peppers, and diced tomato smothered in honey mustard. Substitute the side for some sweet potato fries or sweet potato tots for an extra filling! Just $9.00 plus tax 🥦 🫑 #ajsgrilledcheeseshop #healthyoptions #mealprepcomingsoon #wraps #lieats #lifoodies #fitlife #fitness #protein
We made headlines AGAIN!!! Check us out this weekend 🤩 BAYSHORE.GREATERLONGISLAND.COM AJ’s gets set to fully relaunch; new quesadilla menu available Friday
🔹BIG NEWS 🔹 We have been doing some experimenting and have come up with a new little concept ❗️Starting this Friday evening we will feature a “Quesadilla Factory” menu. On this menu we will have some delicious quesadillas such as mac n cheese with bacon, crispy BBQ or Buffalo chicken, Pulled pork quesadilla and much more! We are very excited and these are absolutely delicious 😋 #quesadilla #delicious #lifoodie

Information

Company name
A.J's Grilled Cheese
Category
Caterers
Est
2013

FAQs

  • What is the phone number for A.J's Grilled Cheese in Bay Shore NY?
    You can reach them at: 631-647-9292. It’s best to call A.J's Grilled Cheese during business hours.
  • What is the address for A.J's Grilled Cheese on west montauk highway in Bay Shore?
    A.J's Grilled Cheese is located at this address: 182 West Montauk Highway Bay Shore, NY 11706.
  • What are A.J's Grilled Cheese(Bay Shore, NY) store hours?
    A.J's Grilled Cheese store hours are as follows: Mon: Closed, Tue-Sat: 11:00AM - 9:00PM, Sun: 11:00AM - 8:00PM.