Delicious Duo
Try two of our delicious, traditional cookies paired with an ice cold milk. It's a match made in Insomniac heaven!
Sixpack
Pick six of your favorite traditional cookies.
Sugar Rush (12 Traditional)
A dozen of your favorite delicious traditional cookies.
Major Rager (18 Traditional)
A mix of 18 of your favorite traditional cookies.
Insomniac (24 Traditional)
A mix of 24 of your favorite traditional cookies.
50 Cookies
Mix and match 50 of your favorite traditional cookies! Please note: this item requires an additional hour of baking time, so we recommend ordering in advance.
100 Cookies
Mix and match 100 of your favorite traditional cookies! Please note: this item requires an additional hour of baking time, so we recommend ordering in advance.
Traditional Cookies
Chocolate Chunk
This tasty favorite is packed with chunks of rich, soft chocolate that melts in your mouth.
Classic with M&M's
M&Ms baked into our signature dough, this festive treat is a party for your taste buds.
Double Chocolate Chunk
This cookie is double the fun with chunks of smooth chocolate inside a soft chocolate cookie.
Double Chocolate Mint
Our delicious chocolate cookie baked with rich chocolate chunks and mint chocolate chips.
Oatmeal Raisin
A classic cookie flavor, speckled with plump raisins, and an extra hint of cinnamon.
Peanut Butter Chip
Creamy peanut butter chips melded into a soft peanut butter flavored cookie.
Snickerdoodle
Simple and delectable! Our signature batter topped with a cinnamon and sugar mix.
Sugar
A classic sweet and buttery cookie! Need we say more?
White Chocolate Macadamia
White Chocolate Macadamia cookie is filled with sweet, white chocolate chips, macadamia nuts, and just a hint of coconut.
Vegan/ Gluten Free Choc Chip
Our vegan, gluten-free cookie is made without animal products or by-products and without any ingredients that contain gluten.
Deluxe Cookies
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
This colossal treat is loaded with chunks of Reese's peanut butter cups and baked into a yummy peanut butter cookie
S'mores
This huge cookie indulgence is packed with chocolate, marshmallows, and graham crackers all baked into a chocolate cookie.
Triple Chocolate
This oversized cookie has a delicious mix of semi-sweet chocolate chunks, milk chocolate chunks, and dark chocolate!
Confetti Deluxe
Filled with sprinkles and vanilla chips, our traditional sugar cookie just got a whole lot more fun and a whole lot bigger!
Oatmeal Chocolate Walnut
A spin on the classic oatmeal filled with chocolate chunks, walnuts, brown sugar and rolled oats. No raisins here!
Salted Caramel
The perfect duo, savory sea salt and sweet soft caramel make up this delicious deluxe cookie.
Cakes
10" Cookie Cake
Choose any of our delicious traditional cookie flavors below & pick an optional message to customize your own unique cookie cake. Up to 8 servings.
Mini Cake
Our mini cookie cakes are perfect for satisfying your cookie cake craving. Choose any of our delicious traditional cookie flavors & pick an optional message to customize your own unique mini cookie cake. Up to 4 servings.
Triple Threat Cookie Cake
Introducing our most customizable cookie cake yet, the Triple Threat! This single cookie cake has the power of 3 different traditional cookie flavors of your choosing. Up to 8 servings.
Moon Cookie Cake
Our moon cakes are out of this world and now available with many flavors and message options! You can now select any of our traditional cookie flavors for the crescent moon and cake center. Up to 8 servings.
Brownies
Chocolate Chip Brownie
These gooey chocolate brownies are packed with chocolate chips and baked to perfection.
Wiches
Cookiewich
Cold, creamy ice cream sandwiched between two delicious traditional cookies. Pick your favorite traditional cookies and ice cream flavor. Note: Cookiewiches are delivered unassembled.
Deluxe Cookiewich
Cold, creamy ice cream sandwiched between delicious deluxe cookies. Pick your favorite deluxe cookies and ice cream flavor. Note: Cookiewiches are delivered unassembled.
Bigwich
Two traditional cookies with our insanely-delicious icing sandwiched in between. Pure Awesomeness!
Deluxe Bigwich
Two jumbo deluxe cookies with our insanely-delicious icing sandwiched in between. Pure Awesomeness!
Ice Cream
Ice Cream Pint
Enjoy an entire pint of your favorite Insomnia ice cream flavor.
Ice Cream Quart
Enjoy an entire quart of your favorite Insomnia ice cream flavor.
Small Ice Cream
Enjoy a small cup (2 scoops) of your favorite Insomnia ice cream flavor.
Medium Ice Cream
Enjoy a medium cup (3 scoops) of your favorite Insomnia ice cream flavor.
Add A Scoop
Cookie with a Scoop
A freshly baked warm traditional cookie topped with one scoop of ice cream. Pick your favorite traditional cookie and choice of ice cream flavor!
Deluxe with a Scoop
One freshly baked warm deluxe cookie topped with one scoop of ice cream. Pick your favorite deluxe cookie and choice of ice cream flavor!
Brownie with a Scoop
One warm chocolate chip brownie topped with one scoop of cold ice cream. Your choice of ice cream flavor.
Beverages
2% Milk
What would cookies be without milk? Reduced fat 1% and skim milk also available at select locations.
Bottled Water
A cold bottle of refreshing water.
Chocolate Milk
What would cookies be without milk? Need we say more!
Whole Milk
What would cookies be without milk? Reduced fat and skim milk also available at select locations.
1% Milk
1% Milk What would cookies be without milk? Need we say more!
Location
1579 2nd Ave.
New York, NY
10028
About
insomnia cookies deliver warm, delicious cookies & ice cream until 3AM!